Fayetteville Dining

Gourmet Pizza at Pies & Pints Pizzeria

Known for being a small town with a big appetite, Fayetteville, West Virginia, is a foodie’s paradise. Located in the heart of the New River Gorge, Fayetteville’s local restaurants are anything but ordinary. From eccentric pizza pies to fine dining fare, these trendy spots are favored by visitors and locals alike. 


Pies and Pints Pizzeria 

Pies and Pints Pizzeria, known for its unconventional craft pizzas, was founded in Fayetteville and has expanded over the years to locations throughout West Virginia, Ohio, Alabama, and more! From a simple house pie to one of their famous specialty pies like the Chicken Gouda or Grape & Gorgonzola, Pies and Pints has a pizza for every palate. An extensive list of draft beers, ciders, and wine rounds out the menu. Pies and Pints offer carry-out and indoor and outdoor dining. Check their website for more information. 


Cathedral Cafe 

Cathedral Cafe has been a community staple in Fayetteville since its opening in 2000. Located in an old stone church with walls lined with books, the cafe is known for its organic, fair-trade coffee beverages as well as its large menu of breakfast, lunch, and dinner items. Specialties range from breakfast frittatas, paninis, rotating house-made soups, and sweet favorites like cinnamon rolls and carrot cake. Cathedral Cafe has indoor and outdoor seating and you can always order carry-out! Stay updated with Cathedral Cafe’s daily menu by following them on social media


Southside Junction Tap House

Located on the corner of Court Street in downtown Fayetteville, Southside Junction Tap House is a local hangout offering twelve rotating taps of local craft beer. Along with beer, Southside Junction also offers munchies like southwest egg rolls and gouda mac and cheese bites, as well as burgers, brats, and a variety of tacos. Southside Junction Tap House had indoor dining, and carry-out and hosts some amazing events! Follow their social media to receive updates on their special menu items.


Firecreek BBQ & Steaks

Voted “Best BBQ” by Blue Ridge Outdoors, Firecreek BBQ & Steaks is a locally-owned restaurant serving freshly smoked ribs, wings, brisket, and more! Since opening in 2018, Firecreek has become a popular spot among visitors and locals looking for homemade comfort food. Firecreek offers the best cuts of steak in the area, signature entrées like Loaded Firecreek Mac ‘n Cheese and Atlantic Salmon, as well as a full bar. Firecreek BBQ & Steaks has inside dining, outdoor dining (weather permitting), and carry-out. Follow them on social media to stay updated.


The Takeout 

There is certainly no shortage of unique and delicious restaurants in this small town. The only problem is choosing where to eat next. Add the Takeout to your list of options.  Choose your base,  your protein, and your flavor, or go with a house special. Gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan options.  If you’re in a hurry to get outside and play, grab a mighty muffin, power bites, and a cold drink. check out the menu, stop in, or order online!


Elliott’s Whitewater Bar & Grill 

Established in 1987, Elliott’s has been a local favorite for over 35 years. Located inside of the Quality Inn, this is a great place to catch the game, have some good food and just kick back for a good time.  Open for lunch, dinner, and a little nightlife. From salads to sandwiches to steaks  – check out the menu and plan your visit.


Looking for the Secret Sandwich Society? They will be reopening in the same location in late spring 2023!